Look there is a world of difference between us and the Shias regarding the belief of
Imaamat. You go on speaking lies and thereafter link us to the Shias.
G- Do the rulings of the Ahle Hadith and the Shias have any similarity?
S- O yes!
G- Which ruling of the Ahle Hadith and Shias is the same?
S- 1)Nawaab Noorul Hasan Khan who is a Ghair muqallid says that the saying of a
Sahabi Z is not a valid proof, (Urful Jaadi pg.207 vol.1) and this is precisely what the
Shias believe.
2) Waheeduz Zamaan a Ghair muqallid scholar says it is okay to say 'yaa Ali or yaa
Muhammed', (Hadiyyatul Mahdi pg.24) and this is also a Shiite belief.
3) He also says that there is no consensus on giving preference to Shaikhain (Abu
Bakr Z and Umar Z over all other Sahaba (R.A)), (Hadiyyatul Mahdi pg.94) this is also a
Shiite belief.
33
4) To mention the names of the Khulafaa-e-raashiDeen in the (Friday) sermon is an
innovation, (Hadiyyatul Mahdi pg.90) this is also a Shiite belief.
5) The modern Ulama can be superior to the Sahaba (R.A), (Hadiyyatul Mahdi
pg.118) this is also a Shiite belief.
6) According to you, one may commit sodomy with ones wife, (Hadiyyatul Mahdi
pg.118) this also a Shiite belief. (Al-isthibsawr pg.243 vol.2 with reference, Irshaadushia)
7) According to you three divorces given in one sitting is equivalent to one divorce
only, this is neither the belief of Imam Bukhari (R.A) nor the four Imams, but it is a
Shiite belief.
8) You reject consensus, and so do the Shias.
9) You also accept temporary marriages, (Hadiyyatul Mahdi pg.118) this also is a
Shiite belief.
10) Listen further! The Ghair muqallid scholar Waheeduz Zamaan says, 'We are the
followers of Ali Z' (Hadiyyatul Mahdi pg.100)
Now tell me. Are we and the Shias alike, or you and the Shias? Ask Allaah for guidance
and do justice thinking carefully.
__._,_.___
| Reply via web post | Reply to sender | Reply to group | Start a New Topic | Messages in this topic (1) |
.
__,_._,___
No comments:
Post a Comment